Inner and Outer Game of Reading
Also how to diagnose exactly where your child is developmentally re schoolwork
Summary ~ Children cannot learn; and, neurological pathways cannot form as easily, when children’s nervous systems are stressed. Forcing young children to write, read, and spell, requiring them to take standardized tests especially on computers, in the early grades, before they are developmentally ready to read and write, further stresses their autonomic nervous systems; therefore, slows development of their brains, bodies, and minds. Children who are pushed to read and write before they are neurologically ready, will dislike reading and writing and may not enjoy going to school at all.
If we insist on pushing writing, reading, and spelling before children’s minds are neurologically fully developed, we will continue to create an epidemic of behavior, attention, and learning challenges in all our children and especially in our boys.
Paragraphing added to this article: “Teaching our children to write, read & spell: Part 1” of two parts
A Developmental Approach Looking at the Relationship of Children’s Foundational Neurological Pathways to their Higher Capacities for Learning
by Dr. Susan Johnson M.D. http://www.youandyourchildshealth.org
The Development of the Balance and Proprioceptive Systems:
There is a widely held belief if we start teaching children to write, read, and spell in preschool and kindergarten, they will become better writers, readers, and spellers by the time they reach the first and second grades.
This, however, is not what I have seen clinically [100 years of Waldorf observation concludes the same]. The truth is children should not be taught to write, read, and spell until their neurological pathways for writing, reading, and spelling have fully formed and matured.
Many neuropsychologists, developmental specialists, occupational therapists, and teachers are concerned our current trend in this country of pushing “academics” in preschool and kindergarten results in even greater increases in the number of children, particularly boys, diagnosed with Attention Deficit Disorders, conduct disorders, as well as challenges in visual and auditory processing [compounded by few to no opportunities to learn thru movement and rhythm, both physical and auditory].
First, the vestibular system, the first sense, even before hearing which the fetus recognizes. Children need to develop a strong sense of balance, both when their bodies are moving and when their bodies are still. Even in utero the fetus is moving and stimulating the three semicircular canals within both inner ears. The semicircular canals are situated so each one responds to a different direction or plane of movement, such as up/down, forwards/backwards, and left/right. The shell-shaped organ for hearing and the three semicircular canals for balance share the same 8th cranial nerve to the brain. If the brain is not getting correct information from the semicircular canals, it cannot easily maintain the uprightness of the body. In this case, children need to think and concentrate to maintain uprightness, and therefore the movements of their bodies are not yet mind-free.
The ability to retain verbal information when sitting or standing depends on the mind being free. This is why a 6 1/2 year old child may be able to remember a sequence of four verbal requests when lying flat on the floor or snuggling in a parent’s lap but not when sitting still in a chair, and especially not when standing still.
Fluid behind an ear drum also impacts a child’s ability to hear as does brain inflammation (often resulting from an inflamed intestinal lining known as “The Leaky Gut Syndrome”). These children have difficulties hearing and understanding language in all positions, whether lying down, sitting in their parent’s lap, sitting in a chair, or standing upright.
In order for a child to be able to sit still, pay attention, and visually remember the shapes of letters and numbers, the child first needs to have developed his or her proprioceptive system, a sense of the body in space. From the time the child is born into gravity, movements of the child’s trunk and extremities will activate proprioceptive receptor sites within the muscles, joints, tendons, and ligaments.
This sensory information then travels to the cerebellum at the base of the cranium as well as to the the parietal lobes, located on each side of the brain, before connecting to all the other brain areas, including the frontal lobes. Movements on the right side of the body are mostly perceived in the left side of the brain, while movements on the left side of the body are mostly perceived in the right side of the brain.
If these proprioceptive pathways are able to fully develop, by the time children are 7 to 8 years of age (a little younger for girls and sometimes older for boys), their brains will have mapped the location of all the muscles, joints, tendons, and ligaments on both sides of their bodies.
Also around this same time period, the right and left sides of their brains will be developing connections with each other, otherwise known as bilateral integration. This will allow children to move the right and left sides of their bodies at the same time. When children can proprioceptively perceive their trunks and extremities and have connected the right and left sides of their brains and therefore their bodies together, they will have developed spatial awareness, a full sense of their bodies in 3-dimensional space (ie. forwards, backwards, up, down, left and right). Their brains and their physical bodies will be now deeply connected. They will be able to locate their trunk, arms, hands, fingers, legs, and feet even when they are sitting still, standing still, or lying in bed with their eyes closed. Their minds will no longer be needed to help keep their bodies upright or judge spatial distances. Their minds will be free to pay attention, focus, and learn. Their minds will also be free to notice nonverbal social cues given by other children and adults.
In my clinical practice I see children who are asked to sit still at a desk when they cannot yet maintain uprightness while sitting or standing, and can not yet “feel” or perceive their bodies proprioceptively.
These children have to constantly move their muscles and joints and often need to seek external pressure to locate their bodies in space. These children often wiggle in their chairs (sometimes falling out of them), lean on their desks, sit on their legs and feet when in chairs, and/or wrap their feet around the legs of chairs just to help their brains better locate the positions of their trunks and extremities.
In addition, when the proprioceptive system has not yet fully developed, children will have difficulties balancing on each foot for 8 to 10 seconds while remaining still when their eyes are closed. Since these children do not yet adequately perceive their bodies in three-dimensional space (ie. forwards/backwards, right/left, and up/down), they also will have difficulties copying forms, especially forms containing diagonal lines, such as the triangle or diamond.
Usually we expect children to be able to copy a triangle by 5 years of age and to copy the diamond shape by 7 years of age. Children who cannot proprioceptively locate their thumbs or fingers when trying to hold pencils or crayons cannot draw easily. In addition, if a child’s brain and mind has not yet started to develop their sense of the body in 3-dimensional space, then diagonal lines are especially hard for this child to copy.
In fact, children will not be able to perceive diagonal lines that are firmly drawn on their backs by a finger, such as in the letters M, W, V, or X or the number 7, until they have fully developed the sense of their bodies in 3-dimensional space. Until that time, diagonal lines drawn on children’s backs will feel like vertical, horizontal, or curved lines.
When not coached by a parent or teacher, children will draw their brain’s proprioceptive connections to their bodies when they are asked to draw a picture of a person. Children less than two years of age usually only scribble when asked to draw a person. Their brains have not yet connected proprioceptively to their bodies.
Girls around two years of age and boys around three years of age usually draw a circle for a head with dangling, vertical sticks for legs and horizontal sticks for arms, all extending out from the circle. This means these children are making proprioceptive connections from their brains to their arms and legs, not yet to their trunks, hands, fingers, or feet.
Usually when girls are around three years of age and boys are around four years of age, they will draw full stick-figures with stick-like arms and legs, originating from stick-like or circular trunks. These children may also draw three to five stick fingers on each of the hands, letting us know that they are beginning to perceive their fingers proprioceptively as well.
Starting around 5 years of age, children should start to experience their bodies in 3-dimensional space (ie forwards/backwards, left/right, and up/down). Reflecting this, their drawings of a person start to show some dimension. Now their drawings will show clothes (ie. triangular shaped dresses or rectangular-shaped pants and shirts), instead of just stick-like or circular, trunks. Their will be tubular or rectangular shaped (rather than stick-like) arms, hands, fingers, legs and feet. The drawings will become more detailed along with the appearance of a neck around 7 years of age. When children draw these types of dimensional drawings for a person, then their brains and minds are getting ready to read phonetically and simultaneously to create mental pictures and scenes from the words they are reading.
If children’s proprioceptive pathways have not yet fully developed or have been partially blocked by unresolved cranial compressions (which can occur during the birth process), their drawings of a person will look like those of younger children, often consisting of scribbles or being stick-like in their forms.
It also is important to realize the social-emotional behaviors of children will parallel the development of their proprioceptive systems. If a child’s drawing of a person proprioceptively appears like a younger child, the child’s social-emotional behaviors will probably be at the age-level of the child’s drawing. This is because a child’s mind needs to be free in order to note social cues. These children will also tire easily and become easily stressed when they are in new environments or social situations because their minds are doing so much multitasking.
Often children whose proprioceptive pathways are incompletely developed are labeled as having Attention Deficit Disorders. They appear fidgety in their movements and have difficulties paying attention and focusing. They often appear stressed and they easily fatigue because of all the multitasking their minds are doing to help their brains keep their bodies upright and judge spatial distances. This multitasking causes children to live predominately in the “flight or fight”, (ie. sympathetic) portion of their autonomic nervous systems. Being in the stressed portion of their autonomic nervous system also causes their pupils (ie. the dark portion of their eyes) to appear large when they are in moderate indoor light. In addition, the movements of these children are often jerky, rather than flowing, and they often seem anxious and/or hyperactive.
Their behaviors can be impulsive and even explosive at times. Often these children have challenges with fine motor finger movements, as well, since they may not yet fully perceive proprioceptively the fingers in their hands. Some of these children may still write with the younger, fist-like grip of their pencils or show lots of tension in their fingers and thumbs when holding crayons or pencils. Once again, these children will be seen as having struggles with peer relationships, because their minds are not yet free and available to notice nonverbal social cues.
Children with proprioceptive challenges may also be labeled as having learning challenges in visual processing (for example, dyslexia or other types of nonverbal learning disabilities), because they have difficulties imprinting and remembering the correct spatial orientations of letters and numbers when they are asked to write them by memory. If proprioceptive pathways are fully developed, children can look at the shapes of letters and numbers, use their eyes to track the exact directions of the lines and curves, and then correctly imprint this spatial information in the left parietal area of their brains. When this happens, children’s minds can form accurate mental images of the numbers and letters they are seeing. If children’s eye tracking, eye convergence, and/or proprioceptive pathways are not yet fully developed or their pathways are partially blocked, these children will confuse letters such as “b” and “d” or may reverse numbers, like 2, 3, or 7, when writing and reading.
The proprioceptive system can also impact children’s lives in other ways. It can affect children’s ability to fall asleep at bedtime and/or remain asleep throughout the night. For these children, closing their eyes at night makes their bodies seem like they disappeared because their minds have not yet mapped the internal connections to their muscles, joints, tendons, and ligaments.
This is why children may frequently wake up during the night seeking physical contact with their parent(s) in order to fall back asleep. When children’s proprioceptive systems are not yet fully developed, they will want to lie next to a parent in order to receive external pressure on their bodies, continually activating the pressure receptors in their skin and the proprioceptive receptors in their muscles, joints, tendons, and ligaments, so they can fully perceive their bodies externally, and therefore relax and fall back to sleep.
This is also why children often want a light on when they go to bed. They need to be able to see their bodies because they cannot yet feel or perceive their bodies proprioceptively when the lights are out.
The proprioceptive system is developed and strengthened in children by having them do large and small physical movements, especially movements where they experience pressure, using their fingers, hands, arms, trunks, legs, and feet. Movements like digging with a shovel, pushing a wheelbarrow, carrying groceries, moving rocks, pulling weeds, hanging from the monkey bars, circle games where their hands are clapping and feet are stomping, jumping, hopping, galloping, and skipping are all wonderful activities for developing and strengthening proprioceptive pathways.
Learning to Write, Read, and Spell:
The conventional educational system teaches children to read in a way which does not make sense developmentally.
Children in preschools and kindergartens are expected to read words when only the right side of their brains have developed. From around three to seven years of age, children are myelinating the right sides of their brains, so they only have access to this right hemisphere of their brains for reading. The right brain can only read individual words by sight recognition or sight memory. Preschool and kindergarten-aged children can only use this developing, right frontal area of their brains to guess at words.
The right frontal area of the brain has a more important task than trying to figure out words by sight. Children need the frontal area of their right brains (and eventually the frontal area of their left brains) to create and analyze mental pictures when they are listening to stories or reading books for themselves.
If children have to use the frontal area of their right brains to recognize words by sight, this area of the brain is not free to create inner mental pictures and scenes associated with the words they are hearing or reading. Furthermore, it is the myelination of the left side of their brains, usually around 6 1/2 to 7 1/2 years of age for girls and at least another year or two later for boys, which enables children to hear the separate sounds within a given word, (ie. phonemic awareness) and string the individual sounds together to sound-out words phonetically.
True reading happens when children can form and create mental pictures in the frontal areas of their right brains; while simultaneously, sounding-out phonetically the corresponding words using the left side of their brains.
It is the formation of mental pictures while reading which gives children a deep comprehension and enjoyment from what they are reading. It is forming of mental pictures while reading which enables children later to make sense of math word problems, algebra, biology, chemistry, and physics; and, deeply to understand literature, poetry, and history.
Mental picturing while reading allows children to verbally express and write down their thoughts and ideas, using their own words, and helps them remember what they have read (ie. pictured) for their entire lives. In addition, when children read phonetically, by sounding-out the words using the left side of their brains, they will have a much easier time with spelling.
In the past, children were taught to recognize only a few hundred words by right brain, sight recognition. These words were usually very short (ie. is, a, and, at, the, are) and did not carry any associated mental pictures.
If children cannot create or form mental pictures while reading, they are forced to memorize the words they see. When these right brain, sight readers are then asked to write a report, they can only parrot back the words or sentences they have memorized. These are then the children who plagiarize or copy something verbatim from a book word for word when they are asked to write reports. This is because they can only recall the exact words they read and memorized by sight. They have no internal mental pictures of their own to refer to. It is internal imaging which enables children to summarize, condense, and more deeply comprehend what they are reading.
This is how and why our current educational curriculum, which pushes reading in preschools and kindergartens, is creating problems with attention and nonverbal learning disabilities in our children.
I notice when children use their right brain, sight memory, to guess at a word’s identity, they mostly focus on the first and last letters of a word, the word’s overall shape, and its length.
This means these children are often oblivious to the sequence of letters within the middle of the words. Usually the children pushed to read since preschool and/or kindergarten have memorized thousands of words by right brain, sight memory. Therefore, these children do not usually notice any differences when shown the sentences, “GAOTS LKIE GARSS” versus “GOATS LIKE GRASS”, “CTAS HVAE TIALS” versus “CATS HAVE TAILS”, or “BAERS LVOE HNOEY” versus “BEARS LOVE HONEY”.
Children can look individually at each letter and compare the spelling of each word, if asked, but they do not see the differences right away when reading. On the other hand, a child who is reading phonetically, because he or she is sounding-out the words, immediately notices all the misspelled words and even tries to phonetically sound-out the nonsense words.
I have noticed in children phonetic-based reading, using the left hemisphere of the brain, usually starts to develop around the same time as the bilateral integration pathways, those connecting right and left sides of their brains, and therefore their bodies, together (crossing the midline).
A physical sign children have developed their bilateral integration pathways is shown by their abilities to perform the cross-lateral skipping pattern (ie. opposite leg to arm, extending) without having to think or concentrate. This is because moving the extremities on the right side of the body is connected to the frontal motor area in the left side of the brain.
Conversely, moving the extremities on the left side of the body is connected to the frontal motor area in the right side of the brain. If children can move their opposite arms and legs at the same time, the right and left hemispheres of their brains are “talking with” or connected to each other. If children can only skip using their feet or only skip extending the same arm with the same leg (ie. the homolateral skip), they are not yet ready to read, since they cannot access both sides of their brain simultaneously.
Jumping rope by themselves in a flowing double jump pattern for every single swing of the rope, both forwards and backwards, also means bilateral integration pathways are forming.
Doing lots of cross-lateral movement activities, in general, helps to strengthen children’s bilateral integration pathways. Movements like:
– jumping rope by themselves,
– noncompetitive swimming lessons,
– rock wall climbing,
– hiking with poles, snow shoeing with poles, cross country skiing with poles,
– Bal-a-vis-x.com (bouncing a ball from one hand to the other while on a balance board),
– contra or square dancing,
– ballroom dancing (in middle school or high school),
– certain EXTRA lesson movements, and of course
– Therapeutic Eurythmy
which in my opinion is one of the most powerful movement therapies for strengthening bilateral integration are all great.
Circle time in kindergarten through the 4th grade at Waldorf and Waldorf-Method schools often includes cross-lateral movements. Doing Spacial Dynamic gymnastic exercises in the older grades is also helpful.
When children are in the older grades, they can do a circus skills camp some summer (e.g. learn how to ride a unicycle while juggling) or learn how to paddle while upright on a flat surf board in still water (a popular sport in Hawaii right now).
Even kayaking, canoeing, and rowing are rhythmic, cross-lateral activities because the trunk and lower extremities hold tension while the arms are paddling. All of these activities strengthen bilateral integration and proprioceptive pathways.
Form Drawing, writing in cursive
Practicing form drawing (also done in Waldorf and Waldorf-Method schools) and writing in cursive, in a flowing manner without pausing between each letter, also strengthens bilateral integration pathways.
Printing just requires the left hemisphere of the brain. Cursive writing requires the right and left sides of the brain to work together. Older children who have not yet fully developed their bilateral integration pathways will find cursive writing very challenging and will prefer to print.
Often too early, we also ask children to hold a pencil and write before they are developmentally ready. I see very young children in preschool and kindergarten being asked to write with one of their hands while they still have overflow movements occurring in the fingers of their opposite hands.
Before six or seven years of age, the vertical midline of the child usually is not fully cognized. Therefore, when a child moves the fingers of one hand, the fingers on the other hand will also move, often without the child’s conscious awareness. Children should not be made to write until this vertical midline is integrated.
Children’s vertical midline is usually integrated after they have developed bilateral integration pathways between the right and left sides of their brain. When this happens, children can cross over the middle of their bodies (ie. cross their midline) with their dominant hands to pick up objects placed on the other side of their bodies.
Also if we force children to hold a pencil or pen and write, before they have integrated their vertical midlines; and, before they have located their thumbs and fingers proprioceptively, they will show tense pencil grips, cramped handwriting, spatially compromised and jerky penmanship.
My greatest concern is I am seeing more and more fourth through eighth graders from public and private schools who are still reading mostly by right brain, sight memory and therefore cannot picture and deeply comprehend what they are reading.
For example, when I give these children the following sentences to read; “Six byos wnet on a vaccaiton tohgeter. Tehy wnet fsihing in a bule baot. One boy cuahgt a big fsih. The ohtres did not ctach a tihng. Tehy dediced to go hmoe”, they often do not notice any of the misspelled words.
Furthermore, when I have these same children read the same sentences with the words correctly spelled, they often tell me that both sentences are exactly the same or maybe only note one or two words, such as “Hmoe or Fsih”, that are misspelled and then tell me that the rest of the words are spelled correctly. Once again, these children are reading both the misspelled sentences and the correctly spelled sentences by sight memory, using only one side of their brains.
I worry these children were pushed to read too early, when only their right brains were developed enough for reading. They compensated by learning to read everything using sight word recognition.
When the left side of their brains finally developed (or myelinated) for phonetic-based reading, they did not easily switch sides. Now they still now read mostly by sight memory. It was only when these children were given new words, words they had never seen before or when they became stuck in their reading, that they would slowly attempt to sound out the words phonetically.
Some children had a strong visual memory for the sequences of letters in words, and they noted misspelled words easily, though they still were reading words by sight recognition rather than sounding them out. This was easy to tell by asking these children to read the words; TRAMS, STOP, and WARTS, backwards. If the children were reading phonetically then it was easy for them to sound-out the words backwards and quickly respond; SMART, POTS, and STRAW. If children were only reading the words by sight recognition, they struggled trying to read these words phonetically backwards.
Most importantly, none of the children who were predominately reading by right brain, sight memory could easily make mental pictures or create scenes while reading words. Some of these children told me that they never formed pictures in their minds when they read, and they only made pictures in their minds when someone else read to them or if they listened to books on tape.
Some children, who were reading mostly by sight memory, told me they saw a few isolated pictures in their minds when reading, not whole scenes. They did not always fully understand what they were reading; therefore, they did not like to read. Other children told me they could create pictures in their minds as long as they read words very slowly. In this way they could first memorize the words in a sentence, and then they could silently repeat back the sentence to themselves and form mental pictures as a second step.
For children 4th grade and older who predominately read by right brain, sight memory, I often recommend a phonetic-based reading program to switch their reading pathways to their left side, as long as their sensory processing pathways of balance in stillness, eye tracking, eye convergence, proprioception and bilateral integration are fully developed.
If children are showing any signs of sensory processing/integration challenges with touch, balance, proprioception, bilateral integration and especially with their eye movements, then I first recommended Biodynamic Cranial Osteopathic treatments or cranial treatments by a specialized Chiropractor, board certified both in Atlas Orthogonist and Functional Neurology, to help gently, and often non-manipulatively, resolve the cranial compressions.
I then recommend that the child do specific movement therapies such as:
– Therapeutic Eurythmy,
– Extra Lesson,
– Parelli horseback riding lessons (especially bareback),
– Brain Gym,
– HANDLE, or sensory integration therapy
with an occupational therapist who specializes in working with children.
These movements need to be noncompetitive, and the therapists need to avoid over-stimulating the children and activating their fight and flight “stress” responses. Therefore, these therapists need to live in the present movement, be in their relaxed autonomic nervous systems, love their work, and enjoy the children.
Neurological pathways do not form well when children are experiencing external stressors in their environments and internally stressed in their autonomic nervous systems.
There are many causes for having unresolved cranial compressions. These often occur over the cerebellum and brain stem areas at the back of the head and base of the skull. These cranial compressions usually occur at birth, since the cranium consists of plates which can overlap and are very moldable.
Often children who have experienced a C-section birth, prolonged labor (more than 12 hours), a very fast delivery, pitocin induced labor, or the use of vacuum suction forceps at delivery, are at risk for having unresolved cranial compressions.
In addition, once these pathways have more fully opened, these children need a lot of strengthening of their vestibular-balance, eye tracking, eye convergence, proprioceptive, and bilateral integration pathways.
Once these pathways and connections are formed and strengthened, many of these older-grade children will still need tutoring to strengthen their phonetic-based reading skills. Why? Their right brain’s, sight recognition of words became is too dominant and “muscle bound.”
Phonetic-based tutoring is usually only needed for 1 hour, twice a week:
– First, children’s phonemic awareness is strengthened (ie. their ability to hear the separate sounds within a given word).
– Next children need to gain a thorough understanding for word families (e.g. sat, mat, cat, etc.).
– Then, the different sounds vowels can make within words.
– Finally, these children will need to learn spelling rules which determine which sounds particular vowels make within a given word.
All of these activities will strengthen children’s left brains for phonetic-based reading. Even if these older-grade children were taught word families and phonetics in the first and second grades, they may need to revisit these reading skills, since the left side of their brains was probably not developed enough to learn these skills when they were in the earlier grades.
Q: What if the phonetic tutoring does not stick in children’s minds from week to week?
A: Then I know their sensory processing pathways are not yet fully opened and/or developed, so tutoring is slowed or stopped until children have more cranial and/or movement therapies to completely open their pathways.
In summary, reading should be taught in schools only after children have developed the left side of their brains for phonetic-based reading and also developed bilateral integration pathways (connecting the right and left side of their brains together). This will enable children to read phonetically, using the left side of their brains, while simultaneously creating internal mental pictures in the frontal area of the right side of their brains (and augmenting or analyzing these pictures by processing language in the frontal area of the left side of their brains, as well).
Here’s the goal: Children who can simultaneously:
– sound-out words phonetically, using the left side of their brains
– while creating mental pictures in the frontal area of the right side of their brains.
These children will be able to read easily (Outer Game of Reading); and, simultaneously create visual images and pictures in their minds of the content they are reading (Inner Game of Reading).
Such children will be able to discuss or write about what they have read, using their own words, because they can replay the mental pictures and scenes they generated in their minds while reading.
Preventing learning disabilities
Overall, schools and parents support a child’s learning by:
– serving healthy foods rich in protein, good quality fats (especially omega 3 fatty acids and coconut oil), fresh fruits, and vegetables,
– eliminating foods which are highly processed, full of sugar, and contain partially-hydrogenated oils and trans fats occurring when cooking or frying foods in vegetable oils (ie. corn oil).
Adequate sleep increases the percentage of rapid eye movement or REM sleep. A lack of sleep leads to less REM sleep, and therefore, less consolidation of short term visual memories into long term visual memories from the previous day’s lessons.
Drastically limiting screen time (television, videos, and computer games), eliminating it altogether on school nights. This will keep children’s minds free to do their own picturing. Also, their minds will not be stressed by trying to comprehend and process the often violent images shown on screens, and the visual memories children form while learning at school will not have to compete with or be diluted by the rapidly flashing visual images on screens.
Regular rhythms and routines in eating and sleeping, as well as physical activity help promote a more relaxed and integrated nervous system for learning.
Stress inhibits learning
Children cannot learn; and, neurological pathways cannot form as easily, when children’s nervous systems are stressed.
Forcing young children to write, read, and spell, requiring them to take standardized tests especially on computers, in the early grades, before they are even developmentally ready to read and write, will further stress their autonomic nervous systems and therefore slow development of their brains, bodies, and minds.
In addition, children who are pushed to read and write before they are neurologically ready, will dislike reading and writing and will not enjoy learning or even going to school.
If we insist on pushing writing, reading, and spelling before children’s minds are neurologically fully developed, we will continue to create an epidemic of behavior, attention, and learning challenges in all our children and especially in our boys.
First grade is the time to introduce lots of form drawing and learn the shapes of capital letters by relating them to pictures.
Because the reading center (frontal lobe area) in the right brain can visualize individual letters as pictures, it makes sense to first teach children the shape of a letter and its corresponding sound by relating the shape of the letter to actual pictures children can understand and draw.
For example, the letter “M” can be represented by two mountain peaks, covered by a layer of snow, with a valley in between. As teachers we can tell children that the sound “M” is the first sound one hears when saying the word “mountains”. Other examples might include drawing a king out of the letter “K”, a bunny or gentle bear out of the letter “B” or waves out of a “W”.
What does not make developmental sense is expecting children to just memorize the abstract shapes of the letter “F” or memorize phrases like “F” as in the word FOX, “B” as in the word BOY, or “C” as in the word CROCODILE.
These words do not make any visual sense to the reading center in the right brain. The letter “F” doesn’t look like a FOX, the letter “B” doesn’t look like a BOY, and the letter “C” does not look like a CROCODILE.
What about learning numbers? A number can be first taught by relating a number to an actual number of objects (manipulatives) the number represents (e.g. using counting stones or pictures of objects the children actively count).
Also in Grade One, we can have children practice drawing cursive forms, like drawing small case letters in a repetitive row (e.g. drawing the cursive form of “c”, over and over to represent the crest of the waves in an ocean or drawing cursive “w’s” in a row that look like waves). Children can also copy printed letters and numbers from the board and draw letters using their fingers (for example the letter M as represented by two mountains) on each other’s back or in the sand. However, do not expect them to easily write numbers or letters by memory, since they will still show reversals if their proprioceptive systems are not fully developed.
I have learned it is harder for children to learn to write cursive words in a flowing manner during first grade, since their bilateral integration pathways are still developing. However, children can have fun drawing these cursive forms in form drawing exercises, and later they will later be surprised and delighted, when they see these same forms again as they are learning to write words in cursive and not just print them.
Starting in second and third grades, many of the children will have developed their proprioceptive systems and connected the right and left sides of their brain together. Therefore they can be more formally taught to write in cursive, to read phonetically, and to spell without developing attention problems and learning challenges. This assumes that children do not start first grade until they are developmentally ready.
Therefore, it is time to remove the desks from kindergartens and preschools. Our preschools and kindergartens need to fill their curriculums with play consisting of lots of sensory integration activities which strengthen:
– fine motor movements,
– visual motor abilities,
– listening skills,
– muscle tone,
– as well as strengthen children’s social and emotional skills.
Most importantly, to strengthen their imaginative and picture-making capacity by:
– promoting play,
– using puppets and marionettes to visually act out stories for the children to see, and
– by telling children lots of stories and reading them lots of books (initially with pictures representing the moral qualities of goodness, truth, and beauty).
Activities like climbing, running, jumping, hopping, skipping, walking the balance beam, playing circle games, singing, playing catch, doing meaningful chores, painting, coloring, playing hand clapping games, doing string games, cutting with scissors, and finger knitting will all strengthen children’s minds for learning.
Children need these healthy, harmonious, rhythmic, and noncompetitive movements to develop their connections between brains and bodies. This will later free their minds for learning, problem solving, and creative thinking.
It is the movements of our bodies and our love for learning which creates strong foundational, neurological pathways which free the mind for reading, writing, spelling, mathematics, problem solving, and most importantly, creative and imaginative thinking.